CJ's American Grill
American
Exclusive deals
These exclusive deals are only available to Restaurant.com members. Check back often as new offers are added daily.
Dining Discount Pass
Get discounts at over 170,000 restaurants and retailers nationwide.
Location and hours
Location
10095 Main Rd Unit 8 , Mattituck, NY
(631) 315-5311
Hours
More details
Reviews
Overall rating
(142 reviews)
Delicious with a capital "D"
In my opinion, Restaurant.com certificate helped make meal better by better aligning cost with value.
Food was delicious and fresh. Waitress was awesome. Restaurant was clean and Decorated nicely. Will definitely go back!!!
Exceptional service. Fast services. Good choices on menu.
My hubby did not like the string beans that came with his Filet Mignon dinner and the waitress took off 1/2 the price. The hostess kaitlyn was very attentive
food was good and our waitress and service was great
CJ is a bar restaurant serving above average food. The service is excellent.
CJ is a bar restaurant serving above average food. The service is excellent.
The food was terrific, service great. Our waitress was a lovely young lady.
Nice staff, great food, tender chicken, value priced menu!
It was a very busy night and add to that we were trying to make a movie, our server did a great job of taking care of us!!
It was a very busy night and add to that we were trying to make a movie, our server did a great job of taking care of us!!
Great food and friendly service. We will definitely return when we are on the North Fork of Long Island!
Great food and friendly service. We will definitely return when we are on the North Fork of Long Island!
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Food is always fresh and delicious Servers are friendly Nice ambiance
Excellent service. Food was surprisingly excellent and the wine offerings well priced.
The waitress was terrific. Friendly. Funny. Very personable.
The waitress was terrific. Friendly. Funny. Very personable.
The food is delicious and the staff is friendly and courteous
Great happy hour! Great food! Great Service, Sandra our Bartender was great! We ate at bar, $$ moderate price! We re regulars!
The service and staff were nice . The seafood bisque and guacamole chip djp was good but the rest of the food was too salty and did not taste well.. I headed home to a severe upset stomach . Gave it 3 Stars beca
Louise was our waitress and the service was personable and prompt. He food was amazing... only bummer was that I forgot to take my leftovers home!
Everything was so tasty and quality. Very Clean! The only thing I was not a fan of was the 20% gratuity included on my bill. We were only 3 people and would have given the 20% anyway. Luckily we were all very happy with every thing and didn't give a problem. But we were definitely not happy with that. If the service/food was not good we would have adjusted that!!
Great tasting food combined with excellent service made for a really enjoyable experience.
Always good food and local wine; always good service
my husband had the special PRIME RIB he said it was a rubber boot - Had he told me at the restaurant I would have said something to the waitress. We have eaten there before and were never this unhappy
I've been going to CJ's for quite a while and although I enjoy their food and their specials, the regular menu could use an update with some new dishes
Food was very good. Taco Tuesdays for one of us and the ribs for the other.
Happy hour at the bar then dinner in restaurant. Lovely, pleasant staff!
Happy hour at the bar then dinner in restaurant. Lovely, pleasant staff!
Nice waitress and hostess.
Rack of lamb was ordered medium rare, and was serviced medium well. I started eating it, and the waitress inquired as to the food, and I mentioned that it was good, but would have preferred it rarer. They immediately packed up that food for me to take home and the chef insisted on preferring it correctly. I received the new food which was absolutely delicious.
Regular menu is very good and daily specials are great staff so pleasant and prompt always want to please. Owner a super nice guy!
Waitress was great.
Excellent value. Good food and super friendly service.
Excellent lobster roll
The specials are always great and we never go away hungry.
Excellent service and delicious food.
Sandra the Bartender was great! Food was excellent, atmosphere warm and friendly. Will definitely return!
Great service and great food!
Our server Karen was excellent
food was excellent. service was good.
food was great, waitress Karen is one of the nicest caring person/waitstaff we have ever had
Wait staff was EXTREMELY accommodating and attentive!
Server was wonderful, great menu selection
Good service, the meals were delivered in a reasonable amount of time. The food was tasty and fresh. The menu options are limited to a page but you can definitely find something you'll like. The price is moderate, what you would expect.
The bar area is always very noisy and it makes it hard to have a conversation when dining. I know this isn't something that can be fixed, but I do wish they had placed the bar in a different location
Great service & food was tasty
The teriyaki Salmon is excellent, as was our waitress!
Great wine & food prix fixe on Monday nite!
Food is always excellent! The staff is friendly & service is always great!
Great waiters/waitresses. Owners and staff always friendly and professional.
Meal was very good I would recommend
Had to send back my food. Was bad. I've eaten there before and it was good. I'll try one more time
Had to send back my food. Was bad. I've eaten there before and it was good. I'll try one more time
Nice place with very good food and service.
CJ's has such a comfortable and in inviting atmosphere. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Quality of food is always excellent. Have been there many times and never disappointed. Everything we have tried is delicious.
I've been here many times and the food is always good. However this time both dinners were way overcooked.
I've been here many times and the food is always good. However this time both dinners were way overcooked.
Very nice place. Close to Movie theater and the service was excellent.
Great ambience, pleasant surroundings, wonderful waitress (funny, professional and quite entertaining!), lots of good food beautifully presented, incredibly extensive selection of local wines
staff were very friendly and the service was great
Excellent service....very friendly staff. Very comfortable casual dining atmosphere ... Nice lunch menu choices for $10.00 if you are looking for a good value lunch. Will definitely return there.
Meal was superb and staff could not have been nicer. Nice surroundings.
Very good food for a reasonable price.
We both had the salmon with salsa. A salad was included and we got a nice basket of fresh baked rolls. Everything was very tasty. The waitstaff was very friendly and attentive. When my husband mentioned that we were celebrating my birthday, the waitress told us it was on the house. I ordered a hot fudge brownie sundae. It came out with candles in it and everyone in the restaurant sang happy birthday. The sundae was huge and delicious. It was enough for my husband to share it with me.
great service - excellent food - cant ask for more !
We ordered prime rib medium, got well done,the waitress never gave us a steak knife we had to ask for one, the waitress never asked if we needed more water & bread I asked if she went home. WE waited too long for our food & check. Never again!!!!
Our server, Louise, do an excellent job and this will make me return to CJ's. The food was very good and plenty of it!
Warm friendly and casual atmosphere. Sat with Sandra at the bar who took great care uf us.
great food and good prices but very noisy at 6-7 pm because of bar.
The restaurant was busy that night and they were short staffed, but our overall experience was good
CJ's was very comfortable, the food was good, as was the service. We have eaten there a second time and were equally pleased.
CJ's was very comfortable, the food was good, as was the service. We have eaten there a second time and were equally pleased.
The wings andthe Reuben sandwich were great. Tbe portions are a good size. Melissa ate waitress was great too.
my favorite restaurant on the North Fork of Long Island
Food was awesome the calamari and shrimp starter was fantastic and the steak sandwich was unbelievable. Our waitress Melissa was terrific always checking on us see if we need anything
was wonderful
Holiday one waitress not great service.
Casual comfortable atmosphere. Food was excellent. We had baked clams, crab cake, chicken sandwich and the french dip. Service was great. Tina and Melissa took great care of us. Will be our new go to neighborhood place!
Excellent service! Great food!
Nice place...clean....people very nice
This place is always good and our server Karen is the best.
Food was great as always! Good, quick service. Friendly staff.
Great tasty food at very reasonable prices.Great service and very clean restaurant.
The water ice staff was excellent. We all loved the fresh warm bread and garlic butter. Our dinner was delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Great service!
Superior service! Loved the atmosphere! Generous portions, fresh, delicious! Owners came to our table and were very personable!Melissa is awesome!
Superior service! Loved the atmosphere! Generous portions, fresh, delicious! Owners came to our table and were very personable!Melissa is awesome!
The food is good, however, every time we go there the service is a disaster. You have to wait to be seated, there's no host/hostess in sight, and there's no one ahead of you to boot. When you get seated the waitress comes over in a little while. Then it takes about another 15-20 minutes for her/him to return to take your order, again there was only 3 active tables and 2 servers. There is no bussing staff, so the table next to you remains dirty until someone decides to clean them (we finished eating by the time that happened).Overall, if the service improved it would be a good local spot to go.....which is why we try it every few months to see if there's been a change.
Great food. Reasonable prices.
Terrific barmaid on Sunday night
Our server was knowledgable and very pleasant
Had go get up 4x for service regarding ordering, wrong meal arrived, missing condiments, bill.
We had a super waitress who honored our certificate w/o question. Food was outstanding & generous. Will go back again.
It was our 31st Ann - we went out to North Fork (from Freeport) for the day/night. Food was YUMMY (esp the lobster ravioli; the steak tips w/scallions & mozz was also very good but a little salty), service was friendly and atmosphere was lovely. Nice touch w/the cornbread and herbed butter.
Food was terrific. Service was good.
always get an excellent meal there.
Great atmosphere. The Thai Seafood Noodle special was excellent.
Tuna poke appetizer was fabulous and food excellent. They were out of a few iofferrings. Likely due to overwhelming popularity earlier.
Staff extremely pleasant.
Our waitress was friendly, pleasant, and provided great service.
great dinner had the prime rib special
The food was excellent and the waitress wasvery pleasant and helpful. I am afraid the place is so small that people at the bar arerataher noisy. The restaurant really needs a little background music (soft)
The wait staff had to be reminded of missing drinks.
Staff very friendly. Soup, app, and salad fresh and delicious !! We hit Prime Rib special night and could not have enjoyed it any more than we did.
Even though the staff faced some issues Sat night, we were still happy with our experience.
The waitress was friendly aand courteous. The food was delicious and with ample portions of everything
Great bartenders Carolyn and Karen
Our waitress was a sweetheart but not the best at her job but we weren't in a hurry so I guess it was OK. The food was outstanding (all four of us had the prime rib special which was a HUGE portion and well worth the $20 for that, a yummy house salad, fresh veggies and delicious mashed potatoes). There was live music tonight which was good but a little too loud for the space. We'll definitely be back, probably once again on a Thursday to enjoy that night's prime rib special! Plus, we always try to support local businesses.
It was very busy thus EXTREMELY loud!
Nice, clean restaurant with very courteous waitstaff...the food was very good too.
Our bar tender Sandra was great. Well informed about the food anfd gave outsyanding service.
Small restaurant and bar so you always felt part of what was going on. Large tv,s to watch without a sports bar feel. The owner was there and hands on with the coustomers. The food was just great. In the warmer weather there is also outdoor seating.
We love the setting, the staff, the food and our excellent $25 bottle of wine = everything is very welcoming and enjoyable here.
We love the setting, the staff, the food and our excellent $25 bottle of wine = everything is very welcoming and enjoyable here.
The service was very attentiveand the food was good, plentiful and fairly priced. The restaurant itself was lovely
The waiter Christian was very helpful
CJ'S was very cosy , the food was excellent , the service was great & the J (joann )in jc's was very personable . Will definitely go back .
Very good food, different specials, and very friendly wait staff.
We were welcomed by the owners and made to feel very comfortable!
everything good , except , the acoustics are terrible ,,, much too noisy to enjoy dinner and quiet conversation with the people at our table ,,,,
terrific SCALLOPS!
Sensational scallops
This is the third time we've eaten at CJ's and we've never been disappointed. They serve a great house salad with the entrees.
Very good food very good service would come back
Great service. Food was great
The food was good and reasonably priced.
Wonderful, flavorful food and excellent service! Waitress and chef went above and beyond.
Wonderful, flavorful food and excellent service! Waitress and chef went above and beyond.
the waitress Tina was very friendly and responsive to our needs.
Crystal, our server was attentive, food was fine.
So good! I highly recommend. Mondays Wine Pairing Prix Fixe is AMAZING! Great waiter and manager that were very attentive to all diners. Great atmosphere. Busy, great vibe. Food was excellent! Can't wait to go back!
Good food & service. Nice Wine Tasting 4 course Dinner Special.
Service was slow; bottle of requested chilled Rose wine was served warm - needing ice to chill (and dilute).. Poor timing on arrival of food.